PR 443: Moral Extremism

Article Data

URL/PhilPapers Link:

Authors

Spencer Jay Case

Abstract

The word ‘extremist’ is often used pejoratively, but it’s not clear what, if anything, is wrong with extremism. My project is to give an account of moral extremism as a vice. It consists roughly in having moral convictions so intense that they cause a sort of moral tunnel vision, pushing salient competing considerations out of mind. We should be interested in moral extremism for several reasons: it’s consequential, it’s insidious – we don’t expect immorality to arise from excessive devotion to morality – and it’s yet to attract much philosophical attention. I give several examples of moral extremism from history and explore their social-political implications. I also consider how we should evaluate people who miss the mark, being either too extreme in the service of a good cause or inconsistent with their righteous convictions. I compare John Brown and John Quincy Adams, who fell on either side of this spectrum, as examples.

Video Review

Reviewer Reports

nogre0:

Rating: 5

FrankBigTime:

Rating: 25

ArisTHOTtle:

Rating: 25

valpo_k:

Rating: 17

EvolveYourselfTV:

Rating: 25

t0my:

Rating: 25