PR 475: Why Aren’t I Part of a Whale?

Article Data

URL/PhilPapers Link:

Authors

David Builes & Caspar Hare

Abstract

We start by presenting three different views that jointly imply that every person has many conscious beings in their immediate vicinity, and that the number greatly varies from person to person. We then present and assess an argument to the conclusion that how confident someone should be in these views should sensitively depend on how massive they happen to be. According to the argument, sometimes irreducibly de se observations can be powerful evidence for or against believing in metaphysical theories.

Video Review

Reviewer Reports

nogre0:

Rating: 17

ivan_neo:

Rating: 17

unrealbrian:

Rating: 50

cinesemiotics:

Rating: 93

Annfernal:

Rating: 17

DCIBanks:

Rating: 17