Philosophy Roulette Review

PR 517: Is there a Duty to Be a Digital Minimalist?

Article Data

https://philpapers.org/rec/AYLITA

Authors

Timothy Aylsworth & Clinton Castro

Abstract

The harms associated with wireless mobile devices (e.g. smartphones) are well documented. They have been linked to anxiety, depression, diminished attention span, sleep disturbance, and decreased relationship satisfaction. Perhaps what is most worrying from a moral perspective, however, is the effect these devices can have on our autonomy. In this article, we argue that there is an obligation to foster and safeguard autonomy in ourselves, and we suggest that wireless mobile devices pose a serious threat to our capacity to fulfill this obligation. We defend the existence of an imperfect duty to be a ‘digital minimalist’. That is, we have a moral obligation to be intentional about how and to what extent we use these devices. The empirical findings already justify prudential reasons in favor of digital minimalism, but the moral duty is distinct from and independent of prudential considerations.

Video Review

Reviewer Reports

nogre0:

Rating: 67

ivan_neo:

Rating: 67

vipersgratitude:

Rating: 83

FrankBigTime:

Rating: 50

Annfernal:

Rating: 38

ArisTHOTtle:

Rating: 25

3udiamonia:

Rating: 38