Philosophy Roulette Review

PR 546: Meaning without Gricean Intentions

Article Data

https://philpapers.org/rec/CARMWG-2

Authors

Pavese Carlotta & Radulescu Alexandru

Abstract

Gricean theories analyse meaning in terms of certain complex intentions on the part of the speaker—the intention to produce an effect on the addressee, and the intention to have that intention recognized by the addressee. By drawing an analogy with cases widely discussed in action theory, we propose a novel counterexample where the speaker lacks these intentions, but nonetheless means something, and successfully performs a speech act.

Video Review

Reviewer Reports

nogre0:

Rating: 78

unrealbrian:

Rating: 25

FrankBigTime:

Rating: 62

globus_the_elder:

Rating: 75

LukeRebels:

Rating: 83