Philosophy Roulette Review

PR 552: Is pain representational?

Article Data

https://philpapers.org/rec/AYDIPR

Authors

Murat Aydede

Abstract

[Special issue honoring Nikola Grahek] Representationalism in philosophy of perception has become more or less the dominant view. There are various versions of it not all of which are motivated by the same set of concerns. Different metaphysical and epistemological agendas are at work in different strands of the movement. In this paper, I will focus on what has come to be known as strong representationalism. This view has reductive and non-reductive versions, which are usually paired with realist and irrealist versions respectively. First, I will develop a simple, largely empirical, argument against the realist reductive version. Later, rather more briefly, I will extend the argument to cover irrealist representationalism.

Video Review

Reviewer Reports

nogre0:

Rating: 83

Tyndereos:

Rating: 83

mddkyrone:

Rating: 75

LukeRebels:

Rating: 75