PR 615: Awareness as an alternative to abandonment? Critical notice of Herman Cappelen’s The Concept of Democracy

Article Data

URL/PhilPapers Link:

https://philpapers.org/rec/BELAAA-13

Authors

Delia Belleri

Abstract

Herman Cappelen’s book The Concept of Democracy makes a case for ‘abolitionism’, that is, abandonment of the word ‘democracy’ and related terminology (‘D-words’). Cappelen’s strategy includes a direct argument for abandonment, aiming to show that D-words are meaningless; and an indirect argument, based on a comparison of abandonment with other options (for instance, replacement or amelioration). In this critical notice, I focus on his comparative case, arguing that the competing options and their respective challenges are not so well demarcated—where this negatively affects the abandonment proposal. Furthermore, I present and defend a yet unexplored alternative: awareness. Awareness is a worthy candidate for its little costs and significant benefits in comparison to abandonment, thus deserving consideration alongside the options assessed by Cappelen.

Video Review

video review premiering soon

Reviewer Reports

nogre0:

Rating: 83

unrealbrian:

Rating: 75

LuminanceBloom:

Rating: 75

ArisTHOTtle:

Rating: 83

k_pars:

Rating: 75

Adam_tuned_in:

Rating: 75

socnow:

Rating: 75

RaDurden:

Rating: 67