


















    
        
    

    
        

        
            
        
    
        

        
            
        
    




<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>

<rss version="2.0"  xml:lang="en-us"  xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom">
    <channel>
        
            <copyright>© Noah Greenstein</copyright>
        

        

        
            <language>en-us</language>
        

        
            <lastBuildDate>Sun, 02 Aug 2026 18:02:58 UTC</lastBuildDate>
        

        
            <link>https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/crystalwiretreeartist/</link>
        

        
            <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/crystalwiretreeartist/rss.xml" hreflang="en-us" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        

        
            

            <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/crystalwiretreeartist/" hreflang="en-us" rel="alternate" type="text/html"/>
        
            

            <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/crystalwiretreeartist/rss.xml" hreflang="en-us" rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        

        

        

        
            <title>CrystalWireTreeArtist · Reviewers · Philosophy Roulette Review</title>
        

        

        
            
                <item>
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    

                    

                    

                    

                    

                    
                    
                    

                    

                    
                        <description><![CDATA[<h1 id=pr-678-art-or-porn-clear-division-or-false-dilemma>PR 678: Art or Porn: Clear division or false dilemma?</h1><h2 id=article-data>Article Data</h2><h3 id=urlphilpapers-link>URL/PhilPapers Link:</h3><p><a href=https://philpapers.org/rec/MAEAOP rel=external>https://philpapers.org/rec/MAEAOP</a></p><h3 id=authors>Authors</h3><p>Hans Maes</p><h3 id=abstract>Abstract</h3><p>Jerrold Levinson conveniently summarizes the main argument of
his essay Erotic Art and Pornographic Pictures in the following
way:Erotic art consists of images centrally aimed at a certain sort of
reception R1.Pornography consists of images centrally aimed at a certain
sort of reception R2.R1 essentially involves attention to
form/vehicle/medium/manner, and so entails treating images as in part
opaque.R2 essentially excludes attention to form/vehicle/medium/manner,
and so entails treating images as wholly transparent.R1 and R2 are
incompatible.Hence, nothing can be both erotic art and pornography; or
at the least, nothing can be coherently projected as both erotic art and
pornography.1I have argued elsewhere ..</p><h2 id=video-review>Video Review</h2><p>video review premiering soon</p><h2 id=reviewer-reports>Reviewer Reports</h2><h3 id=nogre0>nogre0:</h3><h4 id=rating-78>Rating: 78</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/knife.f54aa2e08204f7bf9e0825c376dfb8d8c2e9971f0faf7b7a773964989fec8a65.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/navel.d7ad5bc076d08724604ad9f2f42d90545f903f76e4ea9e7e0c037e1d22399dfd.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/scream.919bdb84c48010fb92740b9bd946b9a497a85aa27c180600004f05829e475540.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div></div></div><h3 id=unrealbrian>unrealbrian:</h3><h4 id=rating-75>Rating: 75</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/voteyea.4f9573b5787a1b94430e076ca59ce6ed9bce85d9e8ab5c84480ed52cd8f20e5a.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/braindance.eff9226012746837b91992574a0abb9e1735df7cf5fdec71a412f631bcf7aeda.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div></div></div><h3 id=energydahamter>energydahamter:</h3><h4 id=rating-75-1>Rating: 75</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/votemeh.c3050c0de20b920f1145490527ce00dba45b8c7d55eee6b268d348e29668d396.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/knife.f54aa2e08204f7bf9e0825c376dfb8d8c2e9971f0faf7b7a773964989fec8a65.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/voteyea.4f9573b5787a1b94430e076ca59ce6ed9bce85d9e8ab5c84480ed52cd8f20e5a.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div></div></div><h3 id=raderpin>RaDerpin:</h3><h4 id=rating-78-1>Rating: 78</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/braindance.eff9226012746837b91992574a0abb9e1735df7cf5fdec71a412f631bcf7aeda.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/knife.f54aa2e08204f7bf9e0825c376dfb8d8c2e9971f0faf7b7a773964989fec8a65.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/votemeh.c3050c0de20b920f1145490527ce00dba45b8c7d55eee6b268d348e29668d396.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div></div></div><h3 id=crystalwiretreeartist>CrystalWireTreeArtist:</h3><h4 id=rating-78-2>Rating: 78</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/votemeh.c3050c0de20b920f1145490527ce00dba45b8c7d55eee6b268d348e29668d396.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/knife.f54aa2e08204f7bf9e0825c376dfb8d8c2e9971f0faf7b7a773964989fec8a65.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/braindance.eff9226012746837b91992574a0abb9e1735df7cf5fdec71a412f631bcf7aeda.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div></div></div><h3 id=baruday>baruday:</h3><h4 id=rating-42>Rating: 42</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/voteyea.4f9573b5787a1b94430e076ca59ce6ed9bce85d9e8ab5c84480ed52cd8f20e5a.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/turd.684cff7767a5f00a112972ab0412adb24b3a8a9dc4f40ea3e3adc6d2e64ff509.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div></div></div>]]></description>
                    

                    
                        <guid isPermaLink="false">tag:www.noahgreenstein.com,2026-03-30:/prr/posts/pr678/</guid>
                    

                    
                        <link>https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/posts/pr678/</link>
                    

                    
                        

                        

                        <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/posts/pr678/" hreflang="en-us" rel="alternate" type="text/html"/>
                    

                    

                    
                        <pubDate>Mon, 30 Mar 2026 01:16:35 UTC</pubDate>
                    

                    
                        <title>Philosophy Roulette 678</title>
                    
                </item>
            
        
    </channel>
</rss>
