


















    
        
    

    
        

        
            
        
    
        

        
            
        
    




<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>

<rss version="2.0"  xml:lang="en-us"  xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom">
    <channel>
        
            <copyright>© Noah Greenstein</copyright>
        

        

        
            <language>en-us</language>
        

        
            <lastBuildDate>Sun, 02 Aug 2026 18:02:58 UTC</lastBuildDate>
        

        
            <link>https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/thegoodrighthook/</link>
        

        
            <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/thegoodrighthook/rss.xml" hreflang="en-us" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        

        
            

            <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/thegoodrighthook/" hreflang="en-us" rel="alternate" type="text/html"/>
        
            

            <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/reviewers/thegoodrighthook/rss.xml" hreflang="en-us" rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        

        

        

        
            <title>TheGoodRightHook · Reviewers · Philosophy Roulette Review</title>
        

        

        
            
                <item>
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    

                    

                    

                    

                    

                    
                    
                    

                    

                    
                        <description><![CDATA[<h1 id=pr-653-shit-happens>PR 653: Shit Happens</h1><h2 id=article-data>Article Data</h2><h3 id=urlphilpapers-link>URL/PhilPapers Link:</h3><p><a href=https://philpapers.org/rec/GARSH rel=external>https://philpapers.org/rec/GARSH</a></p><h3 id=authors>Authors</h3><p>Pete Mandik</p><h3 id=abstract>Abstract</h3><pre><code>      Abstract In this paper I embrace what Brian Keeley calls in 
</code></pre><p>“Of Conspiracy Theories” the absurdist horn of the dilemma for
philosophers who criticize such theories. I thus defend the view that
there is indeed something deeply epistemically wrong with conspiracy
theorizing. My complaint is that conspiracy theories apply intentional
explanations to situations that give rise to special problems concerning
the elimination of competing intentional explanations</p><h2 id=video-review>Video Review</h2><div class=paige-shortcode-youtube><div class="paige-video ratio ratio-16x9"><iframe allowfullscreen referrerpolicy=no-referrer-when-downgrade src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/Oe2zKDJmB24?hl=en-us&amp;modestbranding=1" title="YouTube video"></iframe></div></div><h2 id=reviewer-reports>Reviewer Reports</h2><h3 id=nogre0>nogre0:</h3><h4 id=rating-67>Rating: 67</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/votemeh.c3050c0de20b920f1145490527ce00dba45b8c7d55eee6b268d348e29668d396.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/turd.684cff7767a5f00a112972ab0412adb24b3a8a9dc4f40ea3e3adc6d2e64ff509.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/knife.f54aa2e08204f7bf9e0825c376dfb8d8c2e9971f0faf7b7a773964989fec8a65.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=112 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/knife.f54aa2e08204f7bf9e0825c376dfb8d8c2e9971f0faf7b7a773964989fec8a65.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=112></div></div></div><h3 id=vipersgratitude>vipersgratitude:</h3><h4 id=rating-22>Rating: 22</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/votemeh.c3050c0de20b920f1145490527ce00dba45b8c7d55eee6b268d348e29668d396.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/turd.684cff7767a5f00a112972ab0412adb24b3a8a9dc4f40ea3e3adc6d2e64ff509.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/grapes.7f3e2cfc8b46576e2b2c8cb6797a96622f1ecdbc018b634ef1334a29214d842b.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div></div></div><h3 id=tyndereos>Tyndereos:</h3><h4 id=rating-42>Rating: 42</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=200 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/turd.684cff7767a5f00a112972ab0412adb24b3a8a9dc4f40ea3e3adc6d2e64ff509.gif style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=200></div><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/voteyea.4f9573b5787a1b94430e076ca59ce6ed9bce85d9e8ab5c84480ed52cd8f20e5a.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div></div></div><h3 id=raderpin>RaDerpin:</h3><h4 id=rating-50>Rating: 50</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/votemeh.c3050c0de20b920f1145490527ce00dba45b8c7d55eee6b268d348e29668d396.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div></div></div><h3 id=thegoodrighthook>TheGoodRightHook:</h3><h4 id=rating-62>Rating: 62</h4><div class=paige-shortcode-gallery><div class="align-items-center column-gap-3 d-flex flex-wrap justify-content-center row-gap-3"><div class=paige-shortcode-image><img class=img-fluid crossorigin=anonymous height=128 referrerpolicy=no-referrer src=https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/voteyea.4f9573b5787a1b94430e076ca59ce6ed9bce85d9e8ab5c84480ed52cd8f20e5a.png style=max-height:7rem;width:auto width=128></div></div></div>]]></description>
                    

                    
                        <guid isPermaLink="false">tag:www.noahgreenstein.com,2025-12-03:/prr/posts/pr653/</guid>
                    

                    
                        <link>https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/posts/pr653/</link>
                    

                    
                        

                        

                        <atom:link href="https://www.noahgreenstein.com/prr/posts/pr653/" hreflang="en-us" rel="alternate" type="text/html"/>
                    

                    

                    
                        <pubDate>Wed, 03 Dec 2025 22:30:50 UTC</pubDate>
                    

                    
                        <title>Philosophy Roulette 653</title>
                    
                </item>
            
        
    </channel>
</rss>
